Amazing Grace Retraction!
Tuesday, February 27th, 2007A few months ago I posted a small article about John P. Rees, who wrote the stanza of Amazing Grace that begins…”When we’ve been there…” My writing attributed that verse to John P. Rees, 1780. One of our astute readers picked up an apparent error in that entry. So, back to my sources I went. And there is in fact a problem. Several hymnals attribute that verse to “anonymous.” Other hymnals list John P. Rees, but with no date of authorship. In looking for John P. Rees, it doesn’t take much to discover that he was an American who lived between 1828-1900, which would make it difficult to write that verse in 1780. 1780 is also the year after the Olney Hymns of Newton/Cowper were published, which also makes it a difficult connection as well. I did, however, find my source for writing that information originally. There is one hymnal, The Covenant Hymnal, which does list the author as John P. Rees, 1780. So, it was not a typo on my part, though with the close proximity to the original publication date, I should have known better! My bad, as they say! Now the question seems to linger about what the real date was. Perhaps The Covenant Hymnal had the typo and it should have been 1870. That would work!
Speaking of the Evangelical Covenant denomination, they are great people. I was born in Swedish Covenant Hospital, my first church music position was at a Covenant church, and the guy who has an office next to me is Covenant…so Covenant are good, but we found an error in their hymnal. I’ll let them trace down the true answer!
So, Jubal, see how easy things were before anything was published?